Skip to content

Criticism of Wilmar continues: Amnesty International finds labour violations

West Kalimantan Boy collecting Fresh Fruit Bunches (FFB) in an oil palm plantation. Sanggau, West Kalimantan. November 2005. | Bild: Wakx [CC BY-NC-SA 2.0] - flickr

Whether Nestlé, Unilever, Procter & Gamble or Kellogg’s, palm oil is included in almost all branded products. Behind it is often one name: Wilmar, an agrarian company and leading palm oil producer. Especially in Indonesia, the Group operates through a subsidiary and has been implicated in forced labor, discrimination, low-income and child labor, as Amnesty International reported in a report from 2016. The non-governmental organization urged Wilmar and the Indonesian government to undertake further investigations in the face of these grievances.1 On the back of this, Wilmar assured that internal audits would be launched.2
However, according to a new investigation by Amnesty International in early 2017, Wilmar did not comply with this pledge. On the contrary, employees were apparently intimidated and forced to sign the allegations or to sign statements denying any grievances on the plantations. And, despite this being a violation of Indonesian law, the government is still doing nothing.3
The Wilmar case also sheds a light on the sustainability group, the Roundtable on Sustainable Palmoil (RSPO). Wilmar has been a member of this initiative since 2005, which is committed to fair and sustainable palm oil production. However, according to Amnesty International, an RSPO membership is not sufficient to ensure fair working conditions. In some cases certificates can prove to be a false illustration of sustainability promises t the consumer. Ultimately, it is up to governments and authorities to ensure a credible audit and compliance with fair standards.4
Wilmar recently rejected all criticism of intimidation and cover-up.5

Facing Finance has reported on several occasions about controversies surrounding Wilmar here on our website, as well as in our current Dirty Profits 5 Report.

German Banks involved in Wilmar: Deutsche Bank, DZ Bank, UniCredit6

European Banks involved : BNP Paribas, UBS, HSBC. See page 39 of the Dirty Profits 5 report for further information.

  1.  Amnesty International (2016): The great palm oil scandal: Labour abuses behind big brand names []
  2.  Wilmar Response News Release (2016): Wilmar seeks collaboration for labour transformation in palm oil []
  3.  Amnesty International (2017): Indonesia: Government must investigate Wilmar labour practices as company attempts to cover up abuse claims []
  4.  Amnesty International (2017): Amnesty International rebukes Wilmar’s tactics and calls on Indonesian Government to Investigate Abuses by Palm Oil Sector []
  5.  Reuters (2017): Palm oil giant denies covering up labor abuses in Indonesia []
  6. financial information taken from our Dirty Profits 5 report german edition []